Crisp Apple AI Feedback Guide

'Privacy Policy' 678x4524

AI is becoming part of how we work, and that includes how people are providing feedback on projects.

We’re seeing more and more clients use tools like ChatGPT to review our work, such as website copy, branding, design, or strategy, before sending their feedback back to the creative team.

And we understand how that can be seen as useful and time-saving. AI can help you organise your thoughts, trim back chunky content, and explore different perspectives.

But when our team receives pages of AI-generated feedback, it takes projects off track and makes everyone lose perspective.

While we also want to work as efficiently as possible, the quality of the finished project of our work is the culmination of our team’s human strategy, experience, and knowledge.

AI can help you organise thoughts and ideas, but it doesn’t have any context or understanding of what you know about your audience or business that informs the feedback or what you are trying to achieve.

So it is important for us to set some boundaries around AI in our project process.

We can’t review lengthy AI-generated critiques, assess every suggestion, explain what we agree or disagree with, and then implement the resulting changes.

AI doesn’t have the full picture.

It hasn’t been involved in the project, and it doesn’t understand the agreed scope, budget, or decisions made along the way. Its suggestions are an external perspective, not a project brief.
The process of validating them all adds significant time and cost that wasn’t factored into the work.

AI can be part of your process for sure, but in order for us to deliver our best work, your project should only have two teams at the table: Our team and yours.

Would you invite someone into a late stage of your project who hasn’t been across any of the briefing, conversations, and meetings and hand over the entire thing for their sign-off and approval? Neither would we.

Make no mistake, we love Chatty G and AI just as much as the next person. Used the right way, it can be an efficient tool for ideation, alliterations, rap songs, and a core collection of fresh Crisp Apple puns.

Use AI the right way

If you’re using AI to review your revisions, make it work for you. The better your prompt, the better the outcome.

If you need to rewrite content, ask AI to make it fit the exact word count of the website or brochure you’re working with. Upload an example of the content you’re trying to match so it has something to work from.

You need to tell it exactly what you want to get the best results, rather than creating more work for the person undertaking the reviews.

If you’re using AI to create instructions, ask it to trim back the waffle and use simple bullet points. The last thing you want is a novel to read through when the same information could have been explained in five steps.

Sarah’s added tip

I’ve found Claude to be much smarter when it comes to wording.

ChatGPT tends to go off on its own tangent and make things up, whereas Claude is generally better at following instructions. That said, you need to know what you’re writing about in the first place so you can check and compare the results.

On the flip side, ChatGPT can actually generate some decent artwork with the right prompting, whereas Claude sometimes looks like it’s using Paint to create the most embarrassingly childlike graphics.

Posted in